Are Tamko Shingles Good? Assessing Their Durability, Installation, and Value

Are Tamko Shingles Good?

Tamko shingles are generally good options for those looking for cost-effective roofing materials with strong warranties and good weather protection.

Tamko offers a variety of shingle options, including 3-tab and architectural dimensional shingles, as well as metal roofing shingles.

Their higher-end lines, such as Stormfighter IR and Titan XT, have impressive durability and performance, surpassing comparable options from GAF.

Tamko shingles are generally cheaper than GAF shingles, except in the premium range.

The warranty policies of Tamko shingles provide coverage for defective materials and labor, with options ranging from 15 to 50 years.

While there have been some customer complaints about shingle delamination, Tamko’s warranties and their Edge contractor program help address these concerns.

Overall, Tamko shingles offer a cost-effective and reliable roofing solution for homeowners.

Key Points:

  • Tamko shingles are cost-effective with strong warranties and good weather protection
  • Tamko offers a variety of shingle options, including 3-tab and architectural dimensional shingles, as well as metal roofing shingles
  • Higher-end Tamko shingles, such as Stormfighter IR and Titan XT, have impressive durability and performance
  • Tamko shingles are generally cheaper than GAF shingles, except in the premium range
  • Tamko shingles offer warranty coverage for defective materials and labor, spanning from 15 to 50 years
  • While there have been complaints about shingle delamination, Tamko’s warranties and the Edge contractor program address these concerns

Did You Know?

1. Tamko shingles are known for their durability and are capable of withstanding winds of up to 130 mph, making them ideal for areas prone to extreme weather conditions.

2. Tamko shingles are manufactured using a unique blending process that includes specially formulated asphalt, mineral stabilizers, and fiberglass matting to provide exceptional strength and resistance to cracking.

3. To ensure the highest quality, Tamko shingles are tested by subjecting them to rigorous weathering conditions, including exposure to high temperatures, UV radiation, and heavy rainfall, to simulate real-life weather challenges.

4. Tamko offers a wide range of shingle colors and styles, allowing homeowners to choose from a variety of options to match their personal preferences and complement the architectural style of their homes.

5. In addition to their excellent performance, Tamko shingles are environment-friendly, as the manufacturing process includes the use of recycled materials and they can be recycled at the end of their lifespan, reducing waste and promoting sustainability in the roofing industry.

Comparison Between Tamko And Gaf Shingles

When it comes to choosing the right shingles for your roof, two prominent brands in the market are Tamko and GAF. Both manufacturers offer a wide range of options to suit different budgets and preferences.

Related Post:  Does Roof Raking Prevent Ice Dams or Pose Risks?

Tamko provides the following shingle options:

  • Elite Glass-Seal shingles
  • Heritage series
  • Stormfighter IR
  • Titan XT shingles

On the other hand, GAF offers 11 types of shingles in different price tiers, including:

  • budget 3-tab shingles
  • performance-oriented Timberline series
  • high-end Designer series

In terms of durability, both Tamko and GAF shingles are generally equal. They offer Class 4 Impact Resistance in their higher-end shingle lines, which means they are highly resistant to impact damage. This is important for areas prone to hailstorms or falling debris.

However, when it comes to wind protection, GAF’s three-tab shingles offer better wind resistance compared to Tamko’s counterparts.

GAF provides a wider variety of color options, with over 30 colors across 5 product variants in the Timberline series. On the other hand, Tamko offers a wider variety of material choices, including metal and other types of shingles.

In terms of pricing, Tamko shingles are generally cheaper than GAF shingles on most price tiers, except for the premium range. Tamko’s top of the line Stormfighter and Titan shingles perform better and are also cheaper than GAF’s equivalents.

Ultimately, the choice between Tamko and GAF shingles depends on your specific requirements, budget, and aesthetic preferences.

Durability And Wind Resistance Of Tamko And Gaf Shingles

Both Tamko and GAF shingles are renowned for their durability and ability to withstand harsh weather conditions. They both offer shingles with Class 4 Impact Resistance, ensuring protection against potential damage from hailstorms or falling debris. Additionally, both brands provide options rated for 110 mph or 130 mph winds, offering adequate wind protection.

Considering the wind resistance of shingles is crucial to avoid costly repairs or replacements. Tamko stands out with their Stormfighter IR and Titan XT shingles, which come with a remarkable 160 mph rated wind warranty. These shingle lines are specifically designed to withstand even the most severe weather conditions.

However, it’s worth noting that GAF’s three-tab shingles offer better wind resistance compared to Tamko’s counterparts. If wind protection is a significant concern for you, it may be advisable to consider GAF shingles, particularly their three-tab range.

Color And Style Options Of Tamko And Gaf Shingles

When it comes to color and style options, GAF has a broader range compared to Tamko. GAF offers over 30 colors across 5 product variants in their Timberline series, allowing homeowners to choose a shingle color that complements their home’s exterior. This wide variety of choices ensures that you can achieve the desired aesthetic for your roof.

Related Post:  How to Tarp a Flat Roof: Essential Waterproofing Guide

On the other hand, Tamko offers a decent selection of color options but does not have as extensive a range as GAF. However, Tamko makes up for it by offering a wider variety of material choices, including metal and other types of shingles. This gives homeowners more flexibility in selecting the right material for their roofing needs.

Ultimately, the choice between Tamko and GAF for color and style options will depend on your personal preferences and the specific look you want to achieve for your home’s exterior.

Warranty Coverage Of Tamko And Gaf Shingles

Warranty coverage is a crucial consideration when selecting shingles for your roof. It reflects the manufacturer’s confidence in their products. GAF offers industry-leading warranty policies, particularly for their premium options. They even provide expanded coverage when combined with other GAF products like ventilation or ridge cap shingles.

On the other hand, Tamko shingles have three warranty tiers of 15, 30, and 50 years, varying with the price bracket. However, specific details about the warranty coverage are not provided in the given information. It is vital to read and understand the warranty terms and conditions before making a purchase decision.

Both Tamko and GAF shingles are rated for Class A heat and fire resistance, offering peace of mind and safety for homeowners. GAF’s premium shingle lines also feature StainGuard Plus, an enhanced anti-algae formula that keeps the shingles clean and attractive for a prolonged period.

To make an informed decision about which brand and product line best suits your roofing needs, it is crucial to evaluate the warranty coverage and consider other factors like durability and cost-effectiveness.

Pros And Cons Of Tamko Shingles

Tamko shingles have both advantages and disadvantages that should be considered when choosing roofing materials.

Pros of Tamko shingles include:

  • Cost-effectiveness: Tamko shingles are more affordable than other brands, offering homeowners a budget-friendly option without compromising quality.
  • Strong warranty coverage: Tamko provides a robust warranty that ensures protection against any defects or issues with the shingles, giving homeowners peace of mind.
  • Good weather protection: Tamko shingles are designed to withstand various weather conditions, including impact and wind resistance, enhancing their durability.

However, there are a few cons to be aware of:

  • Some customers have reported shingle delamination, where the layers of the shingle separate. This can lead to durability concerns and potential repairs or replacement.
  • The lifespan of Tamko shingles may not be as long as some other brands, so this should be taken into account.
Related Post:  How to Fix a Flat Roof: The Ultimate StepbyStep Guide

In terms of cost and durability, Tamko shingles compare favorably to major manufacturers like Owens Corning and GAF. Tamko’s Heritage shingle series is particularly attractive, providing an affordable option with the appearance of wood shakes and a variety of color choices. To ensure optimal installation and performance, it is crucial to hire an experienced roofer. Tamko’s Edge contractor program offers enhanced warranties and an extended Full-Start period, making it easier for contractors to gain expertise with Tamko products.

When deciding on the best shingle brand and type for your roofing project, it is essential to thoroughly research and consider factors such as durability, warranty coverage, color options, and the pros and cons mentioned above.


Check this out:


Frequently Asked Questions

Are Tamko shingles any good?

Tamko shingles have had a somewhat checkered past in the roofing industry, with a long-standing struggle to establish a positive reputation. However, the brand has made notable improvements in recent times. While they still fall short of being exceptional, Tamko shingles can now be considered a decent, middle-of-the-road product. With a rating of 3 out of 5, they offer a satisfactory option for those seeking an average roofing solution.

How long should a Tamko roof last?

The lifespan of a Tamko roof can vary depending on various factors such as climate, environmental conditions, and maintenance. However, the Heritage Premium shingles from Tamko are backed by a 50-year Limited Warranty, signaling that they are designed and expected to last for several decades. Additionally, the 20-year Full Start Period ensures that the shingles are covered for any potential manufacturing defects or issues that may arise during the initial years of usage. With proper care and regular inspections, a Tamko roof can provide reliable protection and aesthetic appeal for a significant portion of its warranty period.

Are Tamko shingles better than GAF?

While the GAF Timberline shingles have been known for their superior quality and features, Tamko shingles present a compelling case for consideration. Tamko shingles stand out due to their remarkable durability, which is especially evident in both their budget-friendly and premium performance options. This enhanced level of durability showcases Tamko’s commitment to providing long-lasting and reliable shingle options, making them a worthy competitor to GAF.

Is Tamko a cheap shingle?

Yes, Tamko shingles can be considered a cost-effective choice as they offer competitive pricing while maintaining excellent durability. Despite being more affordable compared to some high-end brands, Tamko shingles still possess similar qualities and performance. This makes them a viable option for those looking for a cheaper shingle without compromising on quality.

References: 1, 2, 3, 4